I often see questions about the pros and cons of dual citizenship for South Africans, and was even recently asked if I had a blog about this topic, so I thought it would be a good idea to research the current rules around dual citizenship and it’s pros and cons.
Moving to Australia is an exciting journey, but for many South Africans, the question of dual citizenship is an important one. Should you retain your South African citizenship, or should you renounce it?
Understanding the pros and cons of dual citizenship for South Africans can help you make an informed decision.
For many South Africans, obtaining Australian citizenship is a long-term goal. However, unlike permanent residency, citizenship comes with additional rights—such as the ability to vote and hold an Australian passport—but also potential obligations, like serving in the military (if required by law).
The Pros and Cons of Dual Citizenship For South Africans
What Is Dual Citizenship?
Dual citizenship, also known as dual nationality, is when a person is legally recognised as a citizen of two countries at the same time. This means you hold two passports, enjoy rights in both nations, and must also adhere to the laws of both countries.
Not all countries allow dual citizenship, but Australia and South Africa do—although South Africa has strict rules around retaining it. Failing to follow these rules can result in losing your South African citizenship without even realising it, although this may change in the future.
For South Africans moving to Australia, understanding the implications of dual citizenship is crucial before applying for Australian citizenship.
What Is Second Citizenship?
Second citizenship refers to holding citizenship in an additional country beyond your country of birth. The difference is that each country of which you hold citizenship, only recognises you as a citizen of its country, not both. So, if there is no agreement between the countries allowing dual citizenship, you may only be recognised as a citizen of each country individually, not both.
Knowing the difference between second citizenship and dual citizenship is key, especially when navigating South Africa’s strict retention requirements.
The Rights & Obligations of Dual Nationals
As a dual citizen, you gain the rights of both countries, but you also take on the responsibilities of both.
Some rights of dual nationals may include:
- The ability to live, work, and study in both countries without a visa.
- The right to vote in elections, depending on each country’s rules.
- The ability to access social services and healthcare where applicable.
However, obligations can also include:
- Obeying the laws of both countries.
- Possible military service (though this is uncommon in both South Africa and Australia).
- Using the correct passport to enter and exit both countries.
Understanding both the rights and responsibilities will help you decide whether dual citizenship is the right choice for you.
Applying to Retain South African Citizenship
South Africans who wish to obtain another citizenship must apply to retain their South African citizenship before acquiring a new nationality. If you fail to do this, you will automatically lose your South African citizenship upon becoming an Australian citizen.
Now, there is the potential that this will change in the future after a landmark ruling by the Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa that this process is unconstitutional. However, this has not changed legally yet so keep checking this if you’re reading this later – I will make sure to update my post with any changes as they happen too.
To retain your South African citizenship, you need to apply through the South African Department of Home Affairs or your local South African High Commission if overseas. This process includes:
- Completing an application form.
- Providing supporting documents.
- Paying a fee.
- Attending an interview at a South African embassy or consulate if required.
This step is essential if you want to keep your South African passport and the rights that come with it.
The Benefits of Dual Citizenship For South Africans
More Travel Opportunities
Holding both South African and Australian passports opens up greater travel flexibility. Australian citizens can enter many countries without a visa, making travel smoother and more accessible.
On the other hand, your South African passport allows you to visit certain African and Commonwealth nations more easily than an Australian passport does. Having both gives you the best of both worlds.
Political Rights
Dual citizens can vote in both countries, which is an important right for many South Africans who still have strong ties to their home country. If you plan to return to South Africa one day or want to influence the country’s future from abroad, retaining your voting rights is valuable.
Easy to Enter and Exit South Africa
If you keep your South African citizenship, you can enter and exit South Africa using your South African passport. If you renounce it, you may need to apply for a visa to visit your home country, which can be an inconvenient and costly process.
The Disadvantages of Dual Citizenship For South Africans
Extra Admin to Retain
Applying to retain South African citizenship can be a lengthy and bureaucratic process. It requires careful planning and timing to ensure you don’t accidentally lose your South African nationality when applying for Australian or another citizenship.
Costs Of Multiple Passports
Maintaining two passports means paying for renewals, visa applications, and administrative fees in both countries. These costs can add up over time, particularly if you need to renew documents frequently.
An Australian passport currently costs $412 per adult for a 10-year passport, and $208 for a 5-year child’s passport. South African adult passports are $103 for a normal passport or $206 for a maxi passport, and child passports are $103 as well. For a family of 4, that’s a lot of money to factor in!
Dual Obligations
As a dual citizen, you may have responsibilities in both countries, including taxes, legal obligations, and political commitments. If either country changes its laws, you will need to stay informed to ensure you remain compliant.
Career Barriers
Some jobs require exclusive Australian citizenship, such as positions in national security or government. If you aspire to work in such fields, you may be required to renounce your South African citizenship to qualify.
South African Citizenship and Tax Residency
One common misconception is that giving up South African citizenship means you are no longer liable for South African taxes. However, tax residency is not tied to citizenship—it is based on where you earn your income and where you have financial ties.
Even if you renounce your South African citizenship, the South African Revenue Service (SARS) may still require you to pay tax if you have assets, investments, or business interests in South Africa. It’s advisable to seek professional tax advice to understand your obligations fully, as to whether you need to change your tax status in South Africa and how this might tie in with changes in your citizenship.
Dual citizenship can be both a privilege and a challenge for South Africans moving to Australia. While it offers greater travel freedom, political rights, and ease of movement between countries, it also comes with administrative hurdles, additional costs, and legal obligations.
Whether you choose to retain or renounce your South African citizenship, it’s crucial to weigh the pros and cons carefully. Understanding the implications will help you make the best choice for your future.
If you’re planning your move to Australia, check out the Proudly South African In Perth online shop for digital products designed to make your emigration journey easier. From the ultimate emigration checklist to a cost-of-living calculator and emigration budget planner, it’s got everything you need to plan your big move with confidence!
No Comments